Dish Rankings · Ontario
Best Butter Tart in Ontario
Restaurantica’s ranking of every butter tart worth ordering in Ontario.
32 restaurants·84 points·4 diamond·
1Boulangers Midland City Bakers9.1DiamondButter Tart · Midland102The Little Pie Shack8.4DiamondButter Tarts · Fenelon Falls103Black Forest Pastry Shop9.0DiamondButter Tarts · Oakville44Fish N' Fry Inn8.6DiamondButter Tarts · Midland35Thornbury Bakery Cafe8.8GoldButter Tarts · Thornbury46Dino's Fresh Food Deli9.2SilverButter Tarts · Midland37Fresh Roots Cafe9.2SilverButter Tarts · Owen Sound18Locomotive Espresso8.7SilverButter Tart · London29Pie Wood Fired PIzza Joint8.9SilverButter Tart · Port Carling110Tribeca Coffee Co.8.6SilverButter Tart · Oakville111Brightside Deli and Baked Goods9.3Butter Tarts · Collingwood112Global Donuts & Deli9.0Butter Tarts · Sarnia213Moose Winooski's9.0Butter Tart · Kitchener214The Oven Woodfire Pizza8.9Butter Tarts · Bracebridge915Crystal Ball Cafe9.2Butter Tarts · Fort Erie716Blue Willow Tea Shop8.8Butter Tarts · Gravenhurst317Three Tarts8.3Butter Tarts · Ottawa418Soups Up & Sticky Fingers8.7Butter Tart · Sarnia219Tastebuds8.7Butter Tarts · Gravenhurst220The Farmhouse Kitchen9.2Butter Tart · Cambridge121The Saylor House Cafe8.7Butter Tart · Prince Edward County122Chit Chat Café9.0Butter Tarts · Kingston123Sherwood Market & Deli9.0Butter Tart · Ottawa124The Pie Guys Bakery & Cafe8.8Butter Tarts · Port Colborne125Balzac's Guelph8.7Butter Tart · Guelph1