Advertisement
The Tangerine Tortoise is Robby Berry's small Russell Avenue pizzeria, a post-Bleu Turtle chapter built around three-day dough, limited tables, and a tight menu of six 12-inch pies plus salad. Cheese Pizza shows the house style; Asiago & Prosciutto and Hot Pineapple carry the detail.
oddBar is the oddBird team's casual downtown St. Catharines pizza bar, built around Detroit slices, named round pies, wings, a serious beer list, and a 4-6 p.m. slice-and-pint happy hour. Haggard, Buffalo Garlic Parmesan, and Nduja carry the menu's oddball comfort-food identity.
Rollin Pizza is a St. Catharines pizza counter built around maximalist signature pies, a full vegan second menu, Detroit blue-steel-pan pizzas, and group-friendly sizing. Start with Pierogi or Big Papa, then use the vegan lineup or party trays to make the order work for everyone.
Fabio's Pizza is a family-run St. Catharines pizza shop with a pickup-first menu built around house dough, wings, panzerotti, panini, and a veal sandwich that has drawn Ontario Veal Appeal competition attention. The strongest order is still pizza-led, but the full read is an old-school local pizzeria with enough sandwich and combo depth to work for weeknights, families, and group takeout.
House-made pasta, Ontario wine and a polished downtown room make Solaia a refined Italian pick in St. Catharines.
Port Dalhousie Italian with house-made gnocchi, burrata-topped pizza, seafood pastas, lakeside dinner energy and a bottle-list-friendly menu.
Coppola's is a long-running St. Catharines Italian room where family ownership, a refreshed dinner menu, date-night pricing, and event-friendly hospitality make it a reliable pick for pasta, steak, pizza and planned gatherings.
Fresco's Euro Grille is a long-running Fourth Avenue Mediterranean room built around current pasta, meze, pizza, seafood, group dining, and weekly lounge specials.
Johnny Rocco’s is a full-service Italian grill in St. Catharines where a stone-mill setting, a broad pasta-and-griglia menu, and Tapas Thursday turn a familiar neighbourhood format into a flexible night out. The strongest order moves between playful starters such as the Italian Sushi Roll and Zia’s Famous Rice Balls, then settles into composed mains such as Lobster Fettuccine or Risotto con Pollo alla Calabrese.
A long-running St. Catharines Italian spot for familiar pastas, parmigiana plates, pizza, family-style trays, and a house salad locals already know by name.
From Restaurantica's dish rankings — ranked on evidence, not ads.
