Dish Rankings · Ontario
Best Shepherd’s Pie in Ontario
Restaurantica’s ranking of every shepherd’s pie worth ordering in Ontario.
21 restaurants·70 points·2 diamond·
1The Duke & Duchess8.4DiamondShepherd’s Pie · Cambridge52The Olde Angel Inn8.6DiamondShepherd’s Pie · Niagara-on-the-Lake43The Irish Harp Pub9.6GoldShepherd’s Pie · Niagara-on-the-Lake104The Dam Pub Gastropub & Whisky Bar8.9GoldShepherd’s Pie · Meaford45Well Fed Sandwich Shop8.7GoldShepherd’s Pie · Gravenhurst26Baker Street Station9.5SilverShepherd’s Pie · Guelph97Doc Magilligan’s Restaurant & Irish Pub8.9SilverShepherd’s Pie · Niagara Falls38The Usual Suspects Cocktails and Grill8.8SilverShepherd's Pie · Niagara Falls69Squires Gastro Pub8.4SilverShepherd's Pie · Burlington210The Shakespeare Arms8.3Shepherd’s Pie · Guelph411The Griffin Pub8.8Shepherd's Pie · Bracebridge312Paddingtons Pub9.0Shepherd's Pie · Grand Bend113Coach & Lantern8.8Shepherd’s Pie · Ancaster114The Judge & Jury9.0Shepherd's Pie · Burlington415Ye Olde Squire Welland8.9Shepherd’s Pie · Welland216The Black Badger8.8Shepherd’s Pie · Cambridge217Eric the Baker8.9Shepherd’s Pie · Guelph118O'Maggio's Kildare House8.7Shepherd's Pie · Windsor119Handsome Devil Bistro9.2Shepherd’s Pie · Elora120Brazen Head Irish Pub8.9Shepherd's Pie · Toronto221MJ Byrne's Irish Pub7.8Shepherd’s Pie · The Blue Mountains1