Dish Rankings · Ontario
Best Classic Reuben in Ontario
Restaurantica’s ranking of every classic reuben worth ordering in Ontario.
38 restaurants·81 points·3 diamond·
1The Sandwich Nook Restaurant9.2DiamondReuben Sandwich · Windsor42Sandtrap Pub & Grill9.0DiamondClassic Reuben · Niagara-on-the-Lake103Eclectic Café & Catering9.6DiamondReuben Sandwich · Orillia14Billy's Downtown Deli9.1GoldReuben Sandwich · London55JJ's on the Docks Eatery8.9GoldReuben Sandwich · Grimsby16The Merchant Ale House9.1SilverReuben Sandwich · St. Catharines67Lost + Found Café9.1SilverReuben Sandwich · Elora48The Pelham Street Grille9.5SilverReuben Sandwich · Pelham29Sawdust City Brewing Co.8.9SilverReuben Sandwich · Gravenhurst410Concordia Club9.1SilverReuben Sandwich · Kitchener111Mo's Family Restaurant9.1SilverReuben Sandwich · Oakville112Box Social8.6SilverReuben · Elora213Ups N' Downs8.0SilverClassic Reuben · Sarnia214The Corner Cafe & Grill8.6SilverReuben Sandwich · Thornbury115Bugsy's9.0Reuben Sandwich · St. Catharines316The Cow and Sow8.8Reuben Sandwich · Fenelon Falls117Penny's Kitchen Diner & Coffeehouse8.9Reuben Sandwich · Vineland-Jordan218The European Bakery Café8.7Classic Reuben · Owen Sound319Old Mill Family Restaurant8.8Reuben Sandwich · Gravenhurst220Harrison Park Inn Restaurant8.8Reuben Sandwich · Owen Sound221The Judge and Jester8.7Classic Reuben · Grimsby222Louie's Diner9.3Reuben Sandwich · Milton123Fisher's Pier 4 Pub8.6Reuben Sandwich · Hamilton224Brew House on the Grand8.5Reuben · Fergus225Doc Magilligan’s Restaurant & Irish Pub8.9Reuben Sandwich · Niagara Falls2