First time here? Take the 30-second tour of how Restaurantica works!
Warm focaccia is the first thing Capra Toro puts on the table, and it tells you most of what the kitchen is after. Set in Peterborough's Hunter Street West café district, this is a downtown Italian dining room built less around any single plate than around the act of sharing one. Pizza and pasta sit at the centre, but the house bread is what threads the whole menu together.
That bread does real work. It comes out warm with olive oil and parmesan and a dish of marinara, then reappears under the Focaccia di Pollo chicken sandwich, beside the meatballs and sausage of the Carne Al Forno, and scaled up family-size in the weekly bundles. Around it the antipasti lean fresh and direct: a Caprese of fior di latte, Roma tomatoes and pesto; bruschetta brightened with feta, roasted garlic and a balsamic reduction; a Caesar built on romaine, crostini and prosciutto di Parma; house-marinated olives and a garlic pesto bread for the table still deciding. The Casa Insalata pulls in winter greens, arugula, dried cranberries, pistachios and feta. None of it is fussy, and all of it is meant to be passed around.
The pizzas run from straightforward to characterful. A Margherita keeps to tomato, fior di latte, parmesan and basil; The Rocco's Pie pushes the other way, a spicy red base layered with Calabrese salami, Italian ham and pepperoni and finished with a drizzle of honey. The Diavola leans hot with Calabrian chili, the All In piles on meatballs, sausage and pepperoni, and the Napoli reads quieter — garlic confit, caramelized onion and a finish of Maldon salt. The pastas hold their own. Gnocchi arrives in a rose sauce with sun-dried tomatoes, parmesan and goat cheese; the Fungo Della Vita twists linguine through wild mushroom, summer squash and a creamy pesto white-wine sauce, scattered with toasted almonds and pea shoots. There are the upright classics too — chicken and eggplant parmesan, both breaded and laid over spaghetti marinara — and, for the undecided, the Tour of Italy, a single platter carrying focaccia, Caesar, meatballs, sausages, chicken parmesan, linguini alfredo and spaghetti marinara, very nearly the whole kitchen in one order.
What the menu makes plain, the weekly calendar confirms: Capra Toro is built for planned nights as much as walk-in dinners. Wednesday runs as Date Night, a dinner for two that opens with focaccia and a Caesar before settling on a pair of pizzas or pastas. Sunday turns famiglia — a dinner for four with family-size focaccia and salad and a choice of four mains, the sort of standing arrangement that makes a weekend meal into a small ritual. For birthdays, work dinners and larger gatherings, there is a private dining option called Black 13, booked online ahead. Each format is a way of pre-deciding how the table will eat.
Capra Toro has been part of the downtown food conversation since it opened in 2015 — family-run, and built with an eye on its community. Local reporting has followed the kitchen to Kawartha Food Share's Mac & Cheese Festival, the annual Peterborough fundraiser where restaurants cook for a public vote, and Capra Toro has taken a top prize there. The festival suits the place: a night of generous, shareable food in service of a community cause, close to what the kitchen does the rest of the year.
The café district along Hunter Street West runs on coffee, brunch and small storefronts, and Capra Toro holds down the dinner end of it — the sit-down option for a night that wants more than a quick bite. Order the focaccia first, let The Rocco's Pie and a plate of gnocchi meet in the middle, and the evening mostly runs itself. It is comfort food with enough specificity to feel chosen, in a downtown that knows it by name.
Capra Toro's appeal starts with familiar Italian comfort food, but the current menu gives enough detail to make the meal feel chosen: warmed Focaccia, The Rocco's Pie, Gnocchi, Fungo Della Vita and hearty entrees like Chicken Parmesan.
The restaurant is not limited to ordinary dinner service. Weekly Dinner for Two and Dinner for Four formats give diners clear timing hooks, while Black 13 gives larger groups and celebrations a more contained private-room option.
Capra Toro has been part of Peterborough's public food conversation through local coverage of its operator story and festival history. The useful present-day read is a downtown Italian room with community memory behind it.
This is Restaurantica’s own read — synthesized from publicly available sources across diner signal and editorial research, last updated June 2026. It’s our interpretation of the evidence, not a crowd average — and placement is never for sale.
Capra Toro has a clear private-dining angle through Black 13, the lower-level room built for birthdays, work dinners and group celebrations. That gives the restaurant a stronger event-use case than a standard pizza-and-pasta dining room.
Capra Toro reads as a planned-night Italian room: reservations, pizza, pasta, warm bread and date-night structure all point toward a dinner that can carry the evening. It is casual enough for comfort but organized enough for a proper night out.
The menu is easy to share across a group: Focaccia, pizza, pasta and Italian entrees all scale well, and the Sunday Dinner for Four gives families a ready-made format. Black 13 adds a separate answer for larger planned gatherings.
Capra Toro's strongest food identity sits in Italian comfort: warmed Focaccia, sauced Gnocchi, Chicken Parmesan, meatball-heavy pizzas and familiar red-sauce pastas. The menu is not trying to be austere; it is built for satisfying plates.
Between reservations, Black 13 and structured weekly dinner formats, Capra Toro gives diners more planning tools than a simple walk-in Italian meal. It suits birthdays, anniversaries, date nights and family occasions that need a little more shape.
Restaurantica’s write-up above is synthesized from broad public signal — community reviews add the first-person layer. Share the nuances of your visit to Capra Toro in Peterborough: the standout dishes, the room, the service.
Write a review
