Be the first to add a photo! Upload
  • Timothy's Steakhouse

  • 3.0 stars
    (24 reviews, average rating: 3.6/5)
  • Cuisines: Steakhouse
  • * CLOSED *
  • 17035 Yonge Street Newmarket, ON L3Y 5Y1
  • Neighbourhoods: Summerhill, Summerhill North
Recommend Restaurant?
3 people have voted
100% of voters recommend
Bloglink! If you've reviewed this place on your blog,
Add your review to this page!
Restaurant Details
Price range
$$$ ($26-$60)
Incorrect business info? Let us know!
jackic23
6 Reviews
2009/02/12
  • The atmosphere was nice and the staff was...
  • Overall
    3.0 stars
    • Food
      3.0 stars
    • Services
      4.0 stars
    • Atmosphere
      3.0 stars
    • Price Range (per person): $26-$60
    • Visit Again?: Maybe
    • Party Size: 9 or more
  • The atmosphere was nice and the staff was professional and friendly, minus one guy who was very stingy. The food was good but nothing special. The clam chowder was a bit grainy from the potatoes -- it could have been more creamy and rich but I guess that is personal taste. One thing to note is that the table service was very good, they always made sure to have our water glasses filled.

  • Order: caesar salad, clam chowder, prime rib
 
cocobonk
5 Reviews
2008/09/16
  • The long slow decline
  • Overall
    3.0 stars
    • Food
      1.0 star
    • Services
      4.0 stars
    • Atmosphere
      3.0 stars
    • Price Range (per person): $26-$60
    • Visit Again?: No
    • Party Size: 3
  • Timothy's had been a long time favourite for many years and we were assured when the new owners took over earlier this year that the quality of the food would not change. I'm sad to say that the decline has been steep and down to the bottom. The fish was cold, both steaks were over cooked as were the shrimp and the vegetables and baked potatoes were undercooked. The service is very good but it's unfortunate to have to hear the wait staff apologizing for a good part of the evening. My understanding is that the old chef has left. Whoever replaced him needs to learn how to cook.

  • Order: Trout, Steak, Shrimp, Soup, House Salads
 
prime rib
2008/08/24
  • In one word the overall pleasure I got in dinning...
  • Overall
    5.0 stars
    • Food
      5.0 stars
    • Services
      5.0 stars
    • Atmosphere
      5.0 stars
    • Price Range (per person): $26-$60
    • Visit Again?: Yes
    • Party Size: 2
  • In one word the overall pleasure I got in dinning there with one of my friend was AWSOME!The waitress was so friendly!The steak was so delicious and the ice cream was so good!
    Surely would be coming again with more people!:)
    -----diganta

  • Order: prime rib
 
K8
2008/05/09
  • My friends and I treat ourselves to Newmarket's...
  • Overall
    5.0 stars
    • Food
      5.0 stars
    • Services
      5.0 stars
    • Atmosphere
      4.0 stars
    • Price Range (per person): $0-$10
    • Visit Again?: Yes
    • Party Size: 2
  • My friends and I treat ourselves to Newmarket's greatest Greek Salad here as many times as we can during our work week, sometimes even the fries and fabulous gravy (there must be some secret ingredient!). Our daily waiter is friendly, courteous, prompt with serving our meal, and comes back to make sure everthing is just right. It's a treat to be pampered in the middle of a hectic work day!

  • Order: Greek Salad
 
Lisa's Review
2008/05/08
  • I love the atmosphere here, and the food was...
  • Overall
    5.0 stars
    • Food
      5.0 stars
    • Services
      4.0 stars
    • Atmosphere
      5.0 stars
    • Price Range (per person): $26-$60
    • Visit Again?: Yes
    • Party Size: 2
  • I love the atmosphere here, and the food was amazing! The prime rib was so tender! The garlic bread is great, and the service was good. We also hosted our son's baptism lunch there, and the service was fabulous! everyone had a wonderful time, and the food was great!

  • Order: steak and lobster/prime rib
 
Anonymous
2008/04/18
  • Great steaks, shrimp cocktail is huge and the...
  • Overall
    4.0 stars
    • Food
      4.0 stars
    • Services
      4.0 stars
    • Atmosphere
      4.0 stars
    • Price Range (per person): $26-$60
    • Visit Again?: Yes
    • Party Size: 2
  • Great steaks, shrimp cocktail is huge and the atmosphere is quite pleasant. Only one complaint would be the salad (kind of limp). But I don't go to a steak house for the free salad anyway.

  • Order: Filet Mignon and Shrimp Cocktail
 
Kymmy
2008/04/14
  • I have been to Timothys about 10 years ago, and I...
  • Overall
    1.0 star
    • Food
      1.0 star
    • Services
      1.0 star
    • Atmosphere
      1.0 star
    • Price Range (per person): $26-$60
    • Visit Again?: No
    • Party Size: 4
  • I have been to Timothys about 10 years ago, and I remembered it being awesome, so I didn't think anything of going again for my birthday this year. What a dissapointment. First off, the person in coat check was sleeping when we went to give her our coats. I'm not talking sleeping off in a corner, she was sitting at the front desk, head down in full sight of anybody! Then the host had us sit at this giant sized table by the fire, this table could easily be for 8-10 people and it was just the 4 of us. Plus the fire was just blazing, it was really uncomfortable sitting there. My mom's chair had a big hole in it, she nearly fell though went she sat down and the host didn't even seem to care. We ended up switching tables, and waited about 15 min for someone to give us menus and ask us about drinks. I overheard one of the waitresses say to other customers that the place was really busy tonight, but when we looked around there was probably only 8 other tables full! When our meal came we had no utensils, and it took us some time to flag down our waitress and then she forgot about us, she came wandering back over about 10 min later and asked how our meal was, and we had to remind her we needed utentsils to find out!! She muttered an appology and then went and got us some but with no napkins. She just plunked down a handfull of knives and forks in the middle of the table. My and my husbands steaks were edible but barely. You could tell it was frozen and not fresh. My veggies were stone cold. My mom's salmon was nice she said but not worth the cost. Definatley wont go back here again!!

  • Order: Steak, Salmon, bottle of wine,
 
bilium
2008/04/07
  • I had heard recent bad things since this place...
  • Overall
    4.0 stars
    • Food
      4.0 stars
    • Services
      4.0 stars
    • Atmosphere
      4.0 stars
    • Price Range (per person): $61-$100
    • Visit Again?: Yes
    • Party Size: 2
  • I had heard recent bad things since this place was sold or bought out or something - anyway - glad to report that whatever it was that was sucking the life out of Timmies is all better now - Great dinner - I am not fussy but my girlfriend knows a good dish (takes one to know one) and she loved it - service, good - everything - perfect.

  • Order: not telling - you want a review - don't tell me what to do - I'm just like that
 
Mike and Estel
2008/02/14
  • Three years in a row! The food is always...
  • Overall
    5.0 stars
    • Food
      5.0 stars
    • Services
      5.0 stars
    • Atmosphere
      5.0 stars
    • Price Range (per person): $61-$100
    • Visit Again?: Yes
    • Party Size: 2
  • Three years in a row! The food is always excellent and the service is great. We always spend Valentines Day at Timothy's.

  • Order: prime rib, greek salad, jumbo shrimp and clam chowder soup
 
Thurd
2007/11/24
  • WOW! What a bad experience, i decided to take my...
  • Overall
    1.0 star
    • Food
      1.0 star
    • Services
      1.0 star
    • Atmosphere
      1.0 star
    • Price Range (per person): $61-$100
    • Visit Again?: No
    • Party Size: 3
  • WOW! What a bad experience, i decided to take my wife and daughter out for a nice dinner to celebrate my promotion, thought celebrate was clearly the wrong word.

    It was terrible! the salad was warm and the lettuce had turned brown, the prime rib was so tough you needed a saw to cut through it and to top everything off in the meal department the lobster smelled rather odd. When i asked my waiter what is wrong with it, he commented on the freshness of the butter and claimed that it was not his problem it was the kitchen.The most rude waitor!

    The wine was the best part but you needed more than a bottle to forget this night out. Shame...Shame! I will not be back!

  • Order: LOBSTER - PRIME RIB - GREEK SALAD - BOTTLE OF WINE
 
Nearby restaurants
Villa Risi
3.5 stars
< ½ km
Rock n Roll Diner
2.5 stars
< ½ km
Pho Saigon
3.5 stars
< ½ km
more nearby