Black Forest Inn

My family and I have been coming to the Black Forest Inn (Schwarzwaldhaus) for decades, and it's a tradition for special events such as birthdays, anniversaries, graduations, and so on. It has continued to be our favourite restaurant throughout the years, and never disappoints.

The atmosphere is fantastic, with an Austrian/German decor that gives one an authentic European feel. The restaurant itself, from the dining rooms, to the washrooms, to the cutlery is utterly spotless. Different seating areas feature both tables and booths with plenty of room and privacy.

The staff is excellent, with friendly and attentive waitresses, great cooks, and efficient service. I usually see the owner and his wife on hand, whether greeting guests or working in the kitchen, which is big plus.

The restaurant features a large menu with all the standard fare from Germany, Austria, and Central Europe. It may not be fancy, but this authentic, home-cooked European cuisine is the best around. Prices are very reasonable.

I am the third generation of my family to count the Black Forest Inn as my favourite dining establishment, and will continue to do so as it lives up to its reputation as a landmark of Hamilton.

I eaten here for lunch about three times in the last few weeks, and really have nothing to complain about. I must say they've improved on their salad quite a bit from a few months back. It seems fresher now. It's homey food, so I prefer to have something a little more different when I dine out. However, at lunch time this place takes care of your hunger pangs!

HUGE PORTIONS

This is my first time going to a german restaurant, so I didn't really know what to expect.

The first thing I noticed was that EVERYBODY was middle aged and white. I stuck out like a sore thumb.

Our server was nice enough, little bit strange, but food came out fast.

I went such a long time ago, so I can't really recall everything, but I remember the food being a great bang for the buck (especially the platters which are meant for 2 people, but could easily feed 4). It was a bit heavy, but I suppose it was to be expected from eating 4 different kinds of sausages, ham, eggs, sauerkraut, fried potatoes, etc. etc.

Overall, pretty delicious homey meal, would go again, and share a platter with a bunch of friends.

Be prepared to wait..... I think that they purposely make people wait to keep up the hype with this place. The food is fantastic, and very authentic to Germany/Austria. That being said, anyone with an aversion to salt should watch out. I have been here a few times, and have loved the experience everytime..

Our food was cold and so bland! Our server was rude, unattentive, and just as cold as the meal.

We went based on reputation....never again!

We brought a friend who was visiting from Mainz and he thought it was the worst food he's ever tasted. I was so embarrassed :(

This is still on my list of go-to restaurants in the city. Sure it's basically meat and potatoes and tastes home cooked...but when that's what I want, this is where I go. They make an effort to accomodate and are always pleasant. There is a reason this place has been around forever people..good quality and value. I am sure that they serve the occasional bad meal...all restaurants do...but I would place my bet on this place for a good meal over any other restaurant of the type in the area. If you're hunting, give it a try, chances are you will have an enjoyable meal.

I have eaten at the Black Forest several times over the years, and have enjoyed it more at one time than another. To me, it's too much like food you would make at home. When I go out to eat, I prefer something more exotic and different. If you're a "meat and potatoes" sort of person, than you'll enjoy it. On another recent occasion I had their cabbage rolls and wasn't too impressed. Seemed to have more rice than meat. If you want the best cabbage rolls in Hamilton, try Denningers.

the food service and prices have always and continue to be incredible. potato soup is to die for!

have eaten at this restaurant two other times and the food just keeps getting worse. the salad was old and watery and the schnietzel was such a small portion i left hungry, i couldn't even eat the spaetzle because it was so bland, best part was the bread which i tryed to fill up on but i ended up getting fast food later on which is quite gross mind you but much better than this restaurant. don't waste your time or money.

Have eaten at this restaurant since I was young. It has never changed except for a few new menu items. The food has always been great and the prices even better. One of Hamiltons best restaurants!!