The Black Dog Village Pub & Bistro

Review: Wonderful atmosphere, very good service, FABULOUS FOOD!

We started with the cheese plate for two .... four beautiful selections, an opportunity to try some special cheeses.

For our main course, we shared two appetizers ..... a spinach salad and lovely spicy shrimp. Excellent combination. The salad was delicious ... the crunch of bacon and pecans was devine. The shrimp was cooked to perfection ... not an easy feat, I've noticed in restaurants!

I definitely think think this is THE place to eat in Bayfield! Highly recommended!

Review: I have been to this restaurant a number of times (I even went before it became the Black Dog). It was definitely better when I first started going, and seems to be continuing in its decline. I loved the fish and chips when they were first on the menu and really liked them with the salad. Last time I went no salad, too bad. The curry was good and a nice portion. Loved the salmon on potato. I am a fan of a good burger and was really disappointed in the tasteless burger, and would never risk should a letdown again. It always surprises me when a pub can't make a good burger. Wish that things would start to improve here.... Service is spotty, from great to terrible. Once our waitress "forgot" to bring our change before she left for the night (the manager was very apologetic). I have had this happen in Toronto too but didn't think it would happen here.

Review: I ordered a Boddington's, but they were out. They had no other light beers (in a pub?) so I ordered a Leffe which was fine. The meal was a little slow in arriving, but the waitress was nice. My burger was very bland - it tasted plainer than a Big Mac from McDonalds, and came with hardly any toppings, and none that would warrant the $10 price for the burger. It wasn't hot - sort of tepid. The fries were a bit soggy, but at least somewhat tasty. The waitress seemed genuine when I shared my concerns, but the manager didn't come over to follow-up (if the waitress passed on my concerns) except to silently remove a plate. My wife's salad was good, she said, and they gave a refill which for a pub is worthy of recognition. The atmosphere was mediocre, with quite a bit of chatter and no music, and slow meal delivery. And the bathrooms were inadequate.

Review: First ordered a $49.00 bottle of wine only to have it served in a glass that smelled of a dirty rag. When brought to the attention of waitress (we seemed to have 3 that night)I was asked if I wanted it transferred to a new glass, UGH...no. Escargot was luke warm but portabello mushroom was piping hot underneath. Calamari had way too much breading, but dipping sauce was very good. My pasta sauce was like wallpaper paste and no taste. Husband's steak seemed to be good, but twice baked potatoes should be baked. The shell had been deep fried then mashed potatoes put in. When we received the bill, there was no adjustment for the glass of ruined wine. When we asked about it, the waitress who presented the cheque, not the original one, said "I have no idea what went on, so I can't adjust." Nice. Please keep in mind that we were there for lunch the same day and it was fabulous...what a difference a few hours make. Ambiance was not pleasurable, should have sat outside instead of listening to the non-stop loud chattering of the waitresses to the bartender. Music would have been nice.

Review: Best place I have ever been!
I can't count the number of times I've been to this beautiful establishment. Service is great at the bar and on the floor. Every single dish on the menu is great...quote me on that. The fish and chips are possibly the best in Southern Ontario.

The selection on draught (Bass, Mill St., Guinness and more international delicacies) is equalling amazing, perfect for anyone who enjoy's a relaxing pint!

I feel bad for those who had a "bad" experience, they don't know what they are missing.

Cheers!

P.S. If you enjoy a fine scotch...there is no place better!

Review: The staff were quite nice and the pub is warm and welcoming.
The food was not up to par for the cost. The curry tasted like it had been cooking for hours and too concentrated in flavour.
Burger was OK, cooked well done.

Review: An absolutely lovely pub! The atmosphere was warm, charming and inviting, the menu was distinctive, and our dinner exceeded our expectations. If you are looking for a wonderful restaurant for a romantic candlelight dinner in the Bayfield area, you won't find better than the Black Dog.

Review: Satisfied every craving I had when I walked in. Left feeling completely fulfilled.
Great experience.

The best eating-out experience I've had in a long long time.

My pint was professionally poured in a pint glass with the correct matching label - perfection.

Review: We ate outside and had the potato cakes with Salmon. Delicious!!!!!!!!!!!!

Review: Yes I want to take my husband and enjoy the same time...it was great and likely better in the summer so you can sit outside judy